What to Know Before Getting a Cat — A First-Timer's Honest Guide

Cats have a reputation for being low-maintenance pets. And compared to dogs, sure — you don’t need to walk them at 6am in the rain. But “lower maintenance” is not the same as “no maintenance,” and a lot of first-time cat owners are surprised by what they signed up for.

Here’s the honest version of what living with a cat is actually like.

They’re independent, not indifferent

The biggest misconception about cats is that they don’t need you. They do. They just show it differently than dogs.

Most cats want to be in the same room as you. They’ll follow you from the kitchen to the couch to the bathroom. They might not want to sit on your lap, but they want to sit near your lap — on their terms, on their schedule.

Some cats are velcro cats who demand constant attention. Others are more aloof and just want proximity. You won’t know which kind you’re getting until they settle in, which can take days or weeks. Don’t take early hiding or skittishness personally — that’s a cat adjusting, not a cat who hates you.

The point is: cats still need daily interaction, play, and enrichment. A cat left alone with no stimulation will find ways to entertain itself, and you will not enjoy those ways.

The litter box situation

Nobody’s favorite topic, but it’s the single most important thing to get right. A bad litter box setup is the number one reason cats develop behavioral problems.

The basics:

One box per cat, plus one extra. One cat = two boxes. Two cats = three boxes. This isn’t a suggestion — it’s the standard recommendation from every feline behaviorist.
Scoop daily. Cats are fastidious. If the box is gross, they’ll find somewhere else to go. Your laundry basket, for example.
Unscented litter is usually better. Cats have sensitive noses. That lavender-scented litter is for you, not for them, and many cats avoid heavily fragranced litter.
Skip the covered boxes at first. Some cats feel trapped in hooded litter boxes. Start open and add a cover later if your cat doesn’t mind.
Location matters. Quiet, low-traffic area. Not next to their food. Not in a spot where they can be ambushed by another pet or startled by the washing machine.

You will be dealing with litter tracking. Litter gets everywhere — on the floor, between your toes at 2am, in places you cannot explain. A good mat in front of the box helps. Accepting your fate helps more.

Scratching is not optional

Cats scratch. It’s not bad behavior — it’s a biological need. They scratch to maintain their claws, mark territory, and stretch their muscles. You will not train a cat to stop scratching. You can only redirect where they scratch.

What actually works:

Provide scratching posts before they find your couch. Tall, sturdy, and stable. If it wobbles, they won’t use it.
Both vertical and horizontal options. Some cats prefer to scratch upward, some prefer to scratch on flat surfaces. Offer both and see what yours gravitates toward.
Place scratchers near furniture you want to protect. Cats scratch where they hang out. A scratching post in the basement does nothing if your cat lives on the couch.
Sisal rope or cardboard are the most popular textures. Carpet-covered posts can actually teach cats that carpet is an acceptable scratching surface. Not ideal.

Will your furniture survive completely unscathed? Probably not. But with enough appropriate scratching surfaces in the right places, you can minimize the damage significantly.

Cat-proofing is more than you think

Cats climb, squeeze, and investigate everything. Cat-proofing a home is different from puppy-proofing — you’re not just protecting things at ground level. You’re protecting things at every level.

Serious hazards to address:

Lilies are deadly to cats. Not “might cause an upset stomach” deadly — “a small amount of pollen can cause fatal kidney failure” deadly. Easter lilies, tiger lilies, Asiatic lilies, daylilies — all of them. Remove them from your home entirely. This is not an exaggeration.
Other toxic plants include pothos, philodendron, sago palm, and tulips. Check every plant you own against an established toxicity list before bringing a cat home.
Open windows without secure screens are a real danger. Cats fall from windows more often than you’d expect. “High-rise syndrome” is an actual veterinary term. Make sure every window has a screen that can handle a cat pressing against it.
Small objects — hair ties, rubber bands, string, tinsel, ribbon — are swallowing hazards. Cats love playing with these things, and linear foreign bodies (string, ribbon, tinsel) can cause life-threatening intestinal blockages.
Blind cords and similar loops are strangulation risks.

Also consider: open toilet lids, exposed electrical cords, accessible trash cans, and dryer doors left open. Cats will explore all of these.

The indoor vs. outdoor debate

This is one of the most contentious topics in cat ownership, so here’s the straightforward version.

Indoor cats live significantly longer on average. Outdoor cats face risks from cars, predators, diseases, parasites, other cats, and people. They also decimate local bird and wildlife populations — this is well-documented.

That said, indoor cats need more from you. They need daily play sessions, vertical space to climb, window perches, puzzle feeders, and rotating toys. A bored indoor cat will let you know it’s bored — through destructive behavior, excessive meowing, or weight gain.

Some owners compromise with catios (enclosed outdoor spaces) or supervised outdoor time on a harness. Both are solid options if you have the setup for it.

Whatever you decide, make the choice before you bring the cat home. Transitioning an outdoor cat to indoor life is much harder than starting indoor from day one.

The real cost breakdown

The adoption fee is the cheapest part of getting a cat. Here’s what actually adds up.

Ongoing costs:

Food — a reasonable quality food runs roughly $30-60 per month depending on the cat’s size and the food type (wet, dry, or both).
Litter — budget $15-30 per month. More if you have multiple cats.
Annual vet visits — routine checkups, vaccines, and preventatives add up. Pet insurance is worth considering, especially for purebreds with known health predispositions.
Unexpected vet bills — cats are masters at hiding illness. When something does come up, it’s often not cheap.

Upfront costs:

Spay/neuter if not already done.
Scratching posts, litter boxes, food bowls, carrier — the basics add up to a few hundred dollars.
Initial vet visit for a health baseline.

You’ll also replace things. Cats knock stuff off tables. They occasionally vomit on things you care about. Budget a mental line item for “things the cat ruined.”

What you actually need vs. marketing fluff

The pet industry will try to sell you a lot of stuff. Here’s what’s actually worth it and what isn’t.

Worth it:

A sturdy cat tree or tall scratching post. This is non-negotiable.
Interactive wand toys. Cheap, effective, and the single best way to exercise your cat.
A good carrier. You’ll need it for vet trips. Get one that opens from the top — stuffing a cat through a front-loading door is a battle nobody wins.
Stainless steel or ceramic food and water bowls. Easy to clean, don’t harbor bacteria like plastic.

Skip it (at least at first):

Self-cleaning litter boxes. Expensive, often unreliable, and some cats refuse to use them. Start with a simple open box.
Elaborate cat furniture. Your cat may prefer a cardboard box over a $200 cat condo. See what they actually like before investing heavily.
GPS collars for indoor cats. If your indoor cat escapes, a microchip is more reliable than a collar that can come off.
Dozens of toys. Start with a few. Cats are notoriously picky, and the toy they ignore today might become their favorite in three months.

The honest downsides

You should hear this before you commit.

Hair. Everywhere. On your clothes, your furniture, your food occasionally. Some breeds shed less, but no cat is truly mess-free. You will own a lint roller. You will own several lint rollers.

3am zoomies. Cats are crepuscular — most active at dawn and dusk. In practice, this means your cat will sprint through the house at full speed at 3am for no apparent reason. A solid play session before bed helps burn off energy, but it won’t eliminate this entirely.

Furniture damage. Even with perfect scratching post placement, some cats will occasionally go after furniture, carpet, or door frames. This is part of the deal.

Vomiting. Cats vomit more than you’d expect. Hairballs, eating too fast, sensitive stomachs — you’ll get used to the sound of a cat about to throw up on your rug. It becomes a reflex to grab them and move them to a hard floor.

Long commitment. Indoor cats regularly live 15-20 years. This is a two-decade commitment. Make sure you’re ready for that timeline, not just the cute kitten phase.

The takeaway

Cats are wonderful companions — affectionate on their own terms, endlessly entertaining, and genuinely bonded to their people. But they’re not the zero-effort pet some people expect.

Go in with realistic expectations about litter boxes, scratching, costs, and the 15+ year commitment. Set your home up properly before the cat arrives. And don’t be surprised when your “independent” cat follows you to the bathroom every single day for the next two decades.

That’s just cat ownership. And honestly? It’s pretty great.

Harlan Pets helps first-time cat owners keep track of vet visits, vaccinations, and all the things you’re supposed to remember but definitely won’t. Try it free for 7 days — just text the number.